扫码分享
验证：
体验盒子-----=====[ Background ]=====-----
AFDKO (Adobe Font Development Kit for OpenType) is a set of tools for examining, modifying and building fonts. The core part of this toolset is a font handling library written in C, which provides interfaces for reading and writing Type 1, OpenType, TrueType (to some extent) and several other font formats. While the library existed as early as 2000, it was open-sourced by Adobe in 2014 on GitHub [1, 2], and is still actively developed. The font parsing code can be generally found under afdko/c/public/lib/source/*read/*.c in the project directory tree.
We have recently discovered that parts of AFDKO are compiled in in Adobe's desktop software such as Adobe Acrobat. Within a single installation of Acrobat, we have found traces of AFDKO in four different libraries: acrodistdll.dll, Acrobat.dll, CoolType.dll and AdobePDFL.dll. According to our brief analysis, AFDKO is not used for font rasterization (there is a different engine for that), but rather for the conversion between font formats. For example, it is possible to execute the AFDKO copy in CoolType.dll by opening a PDF file with an embedded font, and exporting it to a PostScript (.ps) or Encapsulated PostScript (.eps) document. It is uncertain if the AFDKO copies in other libraries are reachable as an attack surface and how.
It is also interesting to note that the AFDKO copies in the above DLLs are much older than the latest version of the code on GitHub. This can be easily recognized thanks to the fact that each component of the library (e.g. the Type 1 Reader - t1r, Type 1 Writer - t1w, CFF reader - cfr etc.) has its own version number included in the source code, and they change over time. For example, CoolType's version of the "cfr" module is 2.0.44, whereas the first open-sourced commit of AFDKO from September 2014 has version 2.0.46 (currently 2.1.0), so we can conclude that the CoolType fork is at least about ~5 years old. Furthermore, the forks in Acrobat.dll and AdobePDFL.dll are even older, with a "cfr" version of 2.0.31.
Despite the fact that CoolType contains an old fork of the library, it includes multiple non-public fixes for various vulnerabilities, particularly a number of important bounds checks in read*() functions declared in cffread/cffread.c (e.g. readFDSelect, readCharset etc.). These checks were first introduced in CoolType.dll shipped with Adobe Reader 9.1.2, which was released on 28 May 2009. This means that the internal fork of the code has had many bugs fixed for the last 10 years, which are still not addressed in the open-source branch of the code. Nevertheless, we found more security vulnerabilities which affect the AFDKO used by CoolType, through analysis of the publicly available code. This report describes one such issue reachable through the Adobe Acrobat file export functionality.
-----=====[ Description ]=====-----
The Type 1 font parsing code in AFDKO resides in c/public/lib/source/t1read/t1read.c, and the main context structure is t1rCtx, also declared in that file. t1rCtx contains a dynamic array FDArray of FDInfo structures:
--- cut ---
70typedef struct /* FDArray element */
71{
72abfFontDict *fdict; /* Font dict */
73struct/* Subrs */
74{
75ctlRegion region; /* cstr data region */
76dnaDCL(long, offset);
77} subrs;
78t1cAuxData aux; /* Auxiliary charstring data */
79struct/* Dict key info */
80{
81long lenIV;/* Length random cipher bytes */
82long SubrMapOffset;/* CID-specific key */
83unsigned short SubrCount;/* CID-specific key */
84unsigned short SDBytes;/* CID-specific key */
85unsigned short BlueValues; /* Flags /BlueValues seen */
86} key;
87t1cDecryptFunc decrypt; /* Charstring decryption function */
88} FDInfo;
89
[...]
110dnaDCL(FDInfo, FDArray); /* FDArray */
--- cut ---
The array is initially set to 1 element at the beginning of t1rBegFont():
--- cut ---
3035/* Parse PostScript font. */
3036int t1rBegFont(t1rCtx h, long flags, long origin, abfTopDict **top, float *UDV) {
[...]
3045dnaSET_CNT(h->FDArray, 1);
--- cut ---
Later on, the array can be resized to any number of elements in the range of 0-256 using the /FDArray operator, which is handled by the initFDArray() function:
--- cut ---
2041/* Initialize FDArray. */
2042static void initFDArray(t1rCtx h, long cnt) {
2043int i;
2044if (cnt < 0 || cnt > 256)
2045badKeyValue(h, kFDArray);
2046dnaSET_CNT(h->FDArray, cnt);
2047dnaSET_CNT(h->fdicts, cnt);
2048for (i = 0; i < h->FDArray.cnt; i++)
2049initFDInfo(h, i);
2050h->fd = &h->FDArray.array[0];
2051}
2052
[...]
2318case kFDArray:
2319initFDArray(h, parseInt(h, kFDArray));
2320break;
--- cut ---
Parts of the FDInfo structures (specifically the "aux" nested structure) are initialized later on, in prepClientData():
--- cut ---
2949/* Prepare auxiliary data */
2950for (i = 0; i < h->FDArray.cnt; i++) {
2951FDInfo *fd = &h->FDArray.array[i];
2952fd->aux.flags = 0;
2953if (h->flags & T1R_UPDATE_OPS)
2954fd->aux.flags |= T1C_UPDATE_OPS;
2955fd->aux.src = h->stm.tmp;
2956fd->aux.subrs.cnt = fd->subrs.offset.cnt;
2957fd->aux.subrs.offset = fd->subrs.offset.array;
2958fd->aux.subrsEnd = fd->subrs.region.end;
2959fd->aux.stm = &h->cb.stm;
[...]
--- cut ---
The problem with the code is that it assumes that FDArray always contains at least 1 element, whereas initFDArray() allows us to truncate it to 0 items.
When the client program later calls t1rIterateGlyphs(), execution will reach the following code in readGlyph():
--- cut ---
3170/* Read charstring. */
3171static void readGlyph(t1rCtx h,
3172unsigned short tag, abfGlyphCallbacks *glyph_cb) {
3173int result;
3174long offset;
3175long flags = h->flags;
3176Char *chr = &h->chars.index.array[tag];
3177t1cAuxData *aux = &h->FDArray.array[chr->iFD].aux;
3178
[...]
--- cut ---
The chr->iFD values are initialized to 0 by default in abfInitGlyphInfo(), so in line 3177 the library will take a reference to the uninitialized structure under h->FDArray.array[0].aux:
--- cut ---
Breakpoint 1, readGlyph (h=0x61f000000080, tag=0, glyph_cb=0x62c0000078d8) at ../../../../../source/t1read/t1read.c:3179
3179if ((flags & CID_FONT) && !(flags & PRINT_STREAM)) {
(gdb) print *aux
$1 = {flags = -4702111234474983746, src = 0xbebebebebebebebe, stm = 0xbebebebebebebebe, subrs = {cnt = -4702111234474983746, offset = 0xbebebebebebebebe},
subrsEnd = -4702111234474983746, ctx = 0xbebebebebebebebe, getStdEncGlyphOffset = 0xbebebebebebebebe, bchar = 190 '\276', achar = 190 '\276', matrix = {
-0.372548997, -0.372548997, -0.372548997, -0.372548997, -0.372548997, -0.372548997}, nMasters = -16706, UDV = {-0.372548997 <repeats 15 times>}, NDV = {
-0.372548997 <repeats 15 times>}, WV = {-0.372548997 <repeats 64 times>}}
--- cut ---
In the above listing, 0xbe are AddressSanitizer's marker bytes for unitialized heap memory (in a Linux x64 build of the "tx" tool used for testing). The "aux" pointer is further passed down to functions in t1cstr/t1cstr.c -- first to t1cParse(), then to t1DecodeSubr(), and then to srcSeek(), where the following call is performed:
--- cut ---
191/* Seek to offset on source stream. */
192static int srcSeek(t1cCtx h, long offset) {
193if (h->aux->stm->seek(h->aux->stm, h->aux->src, offset))
194return 1;
195h->src.offset = offset;
196return 0;
197}
--- cut ---
As we remember, the contents of the "aux" object and specifically aux.stm are uninitialized, so the code attempts to load a function pointer from an undefined address. According to our tests, the memory allocator used in Adobe Acrobat boils down to a simple malloc() call without a subsequent memset(), so the undefined data could in fact be leftover bytes from an older allocation freed before the faulty font is loaded. As a result, the "stm" pointer could be controlled by the input file through some light heap spraying/grooming, such that the free memory chunks reused by malloc() contain the desired data. This, in turn, could potentially lead to arbitrary code execution in the context of the Acrobat process.
-----=====[ Proof of Concept ]=====-----
The proof of concept is a PDF file with an embedded Type 1 font, which includes an extra "/FDArray 0" operator to set the length of FDArray to 0, as described above.
-----=====[ Crash logs ]=====-----
For reliable reproduction, we have enabled the PageHeap for Acrobat.exe in Application Verifier. In addition to allocating memory on page boundaries, it also fills out newly returned memory with a 0xc0 value, resulting in more consistent crashes when using such uninitialized data.
When the poc.pdf file is opened with Adobe Acrobat Pro and converted to a PostScript document via "File > Export To > (Encapsulated) PostScript", the following crash occurs in Acrobat.exe:
--- cut ---
(2728.221c): Access violation - code c0000005 (first chance)
First chance exceptions are reported before any exception handling.
This exception may be expected and handled.
eax=84ca7ef4 ebx=87edee2c ecx=c0c0c0c0 edx=00000000 esi=012f9a2c edi=00000021
eip=548d0e67 esp=012f99e0 ebp=012f99f4 iopl=0 nv up ei pl nz na po nc
cs=0023ss=002bds=002bes=002bfs=0053gs=002b efl=00210202
CoolType!CTGetVersion+0xafccf:
548d0e67 ff510ccalldword ptr [ecx+0Ch]ds:002b:c0c0c0cc=????????
0:000> k
# ChildEBP RetAddr
WARNING: Stack unwind information not available. Following frames may be wrong.
00 012f99f4 548d1091 CoolType!CTGetVersion+0xafccf
01 012f9a1c 548d1b6e CoolType!CTGetVersion+0xafef9
02 012f9ea0 548d545e CoolType!CTGetVersion+0xb09d6
03 012f9ed0 548d63b1 CoolType!CTGetVersion+0xb42c6
04 012f9eec 548a6164 CoolType!CTGetVersion+0xb5219
05 012f9f14 548a3919 CoolType!CTGetVersion+0x84fcc
06 012f9f34 5486bd5c CoolType!CTGetVersion+0x82781
07 012f9f70 54842786 CoolType!CTGetVersion+0x4abc4
08 012fa224 548ec8bd CoolType!CTGetVersion+0x215ee
09 012fb768 548ed5de CoolType!CTGetVersion+0xcb725
0a 012fc830 548243e6 CoolType!CTGetVersion+0xcc446
0b 012fc92c 54823fda CoolType!CTGetVersion+0x324e
0c 012fc940 54904037 CoolType!CTGetVersion+0x2e42
0d 012fc980 0c146986 CoolType!CTGetVersion+0xe2e9f
0e 012fc9f4 0c16008f AGM!AGMGetVersion+0x23eb86
0f 012fca40 0c16039c AGM!AGMGetVersion+0x25828f
10 012fca6c 0c1603fd AGM!AGMGetVersion+0x25859c
11 012fcaac 0c129704 AGM!AGMGetVersion+0x2585fd
12 012fcd48 62c11f7a AGM!AGMGetVersion+0x221904
13 012fcd88 62c1fde1 BIB!BIBInitialize4+0x7ff
14 012fcd90 62c11ee1 BIB!BIBLockSmithUnlockImpl+0x48c9
15 00000000 00000000 BIB!BIBInitialize4+0x766
--- cut ---
The value of ECX is loaded from EAX:
--- cut ---
0:000> u @$scopeip-7
CoolType!CTGetVersion+0xafcc8:
548d0e60 8b4808mov ecx,dword ptr [eax+8]
548d0e63 ff7004pushdword ptr [eax+4]
548d0e66 51pushecx
548d0e67 ff510ccalldword ptr [ecx+0Ch]
548d0e6a 83c40cadd esp,0Ch
548d0e6d 85c0testeax,eax
548d0e6f 7405jeCoolType!CTGetVersion+0xafcde (548d0e76)
548d0e71 33c0xor eax,eax
--- cut ---
And it is clear that almost none of the memory under [EAX] is initialized at the time of the crash:
--- cut ---
0:000> dd eax
84ca7ef4c0c0c0c0 c0c0c0c0 c0c0c0c0 c0c0c0c0
84ca7f04c0c0c0c0 c0c0c0c0 c0c0c0c0 c0c00000
84ca7f14c0c0c0c0 c0c0c0c0 c0c0c0c0 c0c0c0c0
84ca7f24c0c0c0c0 c0c0c0c0 c0c0c0c0 c0c0c0c0
84ca7f34c0c0c0c0 c0c0c0c0 c0c0c0c0 c0c0c0c0
84ca7f44c0c0c0c0 c0c0c0c0 c0c0c0c0 c0c0c0c0
84ca7f54c0c0c0c0 c0c0c0c0 c0c0c0c0 c0c0c0c0
84ca7f64c0c0c0c0 c0c0c0c0 c0c0c0c0 c0c0c0c0
--- cut ---
-----=====[ References ]=====-----
[1] https://blog.typekit.com/2014/09/19/new-from-adobe-type-open-sourced-font-development-tools/
[2] https://github.com/adobe-type-tools/afdko
Proof of Concept:
https://gitlab.com/exploit-database/exploitdb-bin-sploits/-/raw/main/bin-sploits/47260.zip
体验盒子
